When to Fly Budget Airlines Like Spirit or Frontier (and When to Choose Major Airlines)

If you fly out of Dallas-Fort Worth, you've probably seen those eye-catching fares on Spirit or Frontier—sometimes half the price of American, Delta, or United for the same route. But you've also heard the warnings: hidden fees, cramped seats, delays, and nickel-and-diming at every turn.

So when does it actually make sense to fly a budget airline from Dallas, and when should you stick with a major carrier? The answer isn't black and white. It depends on your route, how much you're packing, how long the flight is, and what you value most—price, comfort, or reliability.

This guide walks through the key decision factors for Dallas travelers, with real examples of when ultra-low-cost carriers like Spirit and Frontier make sense and when a major airline is usually the smarter choice. No hype, no judgment—just practical advice to help you evaluate total trip cost and choose the right airline for your next flight.

What "Budget Airline" Really Means

The term "budget airline" or "ultra-low-cost carrier" (ULCC) refers to airlines like Spirit, Frontier, and Allegiant that use a fundamentally different pricing model than major carriers. Instead of bundling everything into one ticket price, ULCCs strip the fare down to the absolute minimum—a seat on the plane and a small personal item—and charge separately for everything else.

This isn't a trick or a scam. It's a deliberate business model designed to offer rock-bottom base fares for travelers who don't need (or don't want to pay for) carry-on bags, seat selection, priority boarding, or onboard snacks. If you can fit your trip into a backpack and don't mind sitting wherever they assign you, budget airlines can save you real money.

How ULCC Pricing Works from Dallas

What's included in the base fare: A seat on the plane and space for one personal item (usually around 18 x 14 x 8 inches—think a small backpack, purse, or laptop bag that fits under the seat in front of you).

What typically costs extra: Carry-on bag (anything larger than the personal item), checked bags, seat selection, priority boarding, flight changes, and sometimes even printing your boarding pass at the airport if you forget to do it online.

Fee structures vary by airline and route, but as a general rule, expect to pay extra for a standard carry-on roller bag, more for a checked bag, and even more if you add these at the airport instead of during online check-in. Seat selection fees range from free (random assignment at check-in) to premium pricing for exit rows or front-of-plane seats.

What Major Airlines Include (and Don't)

American, Delta, and United also offer "basic economy" fares that restrict seat selection and don't allow changes, but they still include a standard-size carry-on bag that fits in the overhead bin. Regular economy fares on these carriers include carry-on, seat selection, and the ability to change your flight (usually for a fee).

Southwest, which serves Love Field and select DFW routes, bundles even more: two free checked bags, no change fees, and free same-day standby. This makes Southwest's total trip cost lower than it appears when comparing base fares alone.

The key takeaway: Budget airlines aren't necessarily cheaper once you add the services most travelers need. You have to calculate total trip cost to know which airline actually saves you money.

The Key Decision Factors for Dallas Travelers

Choosing between a budget airline and a major carrier from Dallas comes down to five main factors: route availability, total trip cost, flight distance, schedule reliability, and whether driving might make more sense. Here's how to evaluate each one.

Nonstop Routes from DFW vs Love Field

DFW Airport is where you'll find Spirit and Frontier operating most of their Dallas routes. Both airlines focus heavily on leisure destinations—Orlando, Las Vegas, Los Angeles, Cancún, and other warm-weather or entertainment-focused cities. They don't serve every route American flies, but where they do compete, they typically offer lower base fares.

Love Field is Southwest's domain and occasionally sees service from a few other carriers, but Spirit and Frontier don't operate significant service from DAL. If you're flying out of Love Field, you're almost always choosing between Southwest and the handful of routes other carriers serve.

What this means for you: If Spirit or Frontier doesn't fly your route nonstop from DFW, the decision is already made. But if they do, and American or another major carrier also flies that route nonstop, you have a real choice to evaluate.

Total Trip Cost Once Bags and Seats Are Added

This is the single most important factor. A Spirit fare that looks half the price of American might end up costing the same—or more—once you add a carry-on, a checked bag, and seat selection for your family.

How to calculate total trip cost: Start with the base fare on each airline. For the budget carrier, add the cost of a carry-on bag (if you need one), checked bags (if applicable), and seat selection (if you care where you sit). For the major carrier, check whether your fare class includes a carry-on or if you're looking at basic economy with restrictions.

Example scenario: You're flying DFW to Orlando with one carry-on and no checked bags. Spirit's base fare might be lower, but adding the carry-on fee could bring the total close to American's regular economy fare, which already includes the carry-on. If the difference is only a few dollars, the major carrier usually offers better value (more legroom, better schedules, easier changes if needed).

Never miss deals on your preferred airlines

Set up personalized trip alerts and we'll notify you when fares drop on Spirit, Frontier, American, or any carrier serving your route. Track deals across all airlines and choose the best option when prices hit your budget.

Set Up Trip Alerts

Flight Distance and Comfort Considerations

Short flights (under 2 hours): Budget airlines are generally fine for most travelers. DFW to Houston, DFW to Austin, or DFW to Las Vegas are all short enough that tighter seat pitch (the distance between rows) and no frills don't significantly impact comfort. You're in the air for 60–90 minutes, and then you're done.

Medium flights (2–3 hours): This is where personal preference matters. A 2.5-hour flight from DFW to Los Angeles or DFW to Denver is manageable on a budget airline if you're sitting in a standard seat and traveling light. But if you're tall, traveling with kids, or simply value more legroom, the extra cost for a major carrier might be worth it.

Long flights (3+ hours): Budget airlines become noticeably less comfortable on flights over 3 hours. DFW to Seattle, DFW to New York, or DFW to Cancún are all routes where tighter seats, no in-flight entertainment, and limited recline start to wear on you. For these distances, most travelers find that paying a bit more for a major carrier's extra legroom and included amenities is worth it.

Scheduling Flexibility and Delay Impacts

Budget airlines typically fly fewer daily frequencies on each route compared to major carriers. If your Spirit or Frontier flight gets canceled or significantly delayed, your rebooking options are often limited to the next available flight on that same airline—which might not be until the next day.

Major carriers fly more frequencies and have partnership agreements, so if an American flight gets canceled, they can often rebook you on another American flight later that day or even on a partner airline. This makes them more reliable when you have time-critical travel—business meetings, weddings, cruises with fixed departure times.

What this means for Dallas travelers: If you're flying for a vacation and have a day or two of buffer time on either end, budget airlines are lower-risk. If you absolutely must arrive on time or can't afford a missed connection, major carriers offer more backup options.

When Driving May Be a Better Alternative (For Short Distances)

For destinations within 3–4 hours of Dallas, driving can sometimes beat flying on any airline once you factor in total travel time. Getting to DFW, arriving 90+ minutes early for check-in, the flight itself, landing, baggage claim, and ground transportation at your destination can easily add up to 4–5 hours for a short flight.

Examples where driving often makes sense: Austin (3 hours), Houston (3.5 hours), San Antonio (4 hours), Oklahoma City (3 hours). If you're traveling with family or multiple people who can split gas costs, and you need a car at your destination anyway, driving can save both time and money compared to flying—budget or major carrier.

When flying still wins: If you're traveling solo, don't want to deal with highway driving, or your destination has good public transit, even a budget airline can be faster and less stressful than a 3-hour drive. It depends on your priorities and how you value your time.

When Budget Airlines Make Sense

Budget airlines can be genuinely great deals for certain types of trips and travelers. Here's when flying Spirit or Frontier from Dallas usually makes sense.

Short Nonstop Flights from DFW (Under 2 Hours)

Routes like DFW to Las Vegas, DFW to Houston, or DFW to Phoenix are short enough that comfort differences matter less. You're in the air for 90 minutes to 2 hours, and then you're done. Tighter seats and no free snacks are minor inconveniences for such a short duration.

If the budget airline saves you significantly (say, 30–50% less than the major carrier's total cost after adding bags), it's usually worth it for short hops. You can use the savings toward your hotel, entertainment, or meals at your destination.

Travelers with No Bags or Only a Small Personal Item

This is where budget airlines shine. If you can fit everything you need into a small backpack, purse, or laptop bag (around 18 x 14 x 8 inches), you avoid all baggage fees and get exactly what you're paying for—a cheap seat from Point A to Point B.

Weekend trips, business travel with just a laptop, or minimalist packers can save real money by flying Spirit or Frontier with just a personal item. No checked bag, no carry-on fee, no extra charges. The base fare is your total fare.

Pro tip: A well-packed personal item can hold more than you think. Packing cubes, lightweight clothes, and planning to do laundry (or re-wearing clothes) can make a long weekend or even a week-long trip doable with just a backpack.

When Schedule Isn't as Critical

Leisure travel with flexible dates is ideal for budget airlines. If you're going on vacation and have a day or two of buffer on either end of your trip, a delay or flight change is more of an inconvenience than a crisis.

Avoid budget airlines when: You have a tight connection, a cruise departure, a wedding to attend, or any time-critical event. The risk of delays with limited rebooking options isn't worth the savings in these scenarios.

Track deals on your favorite routes

Whether you prefer budget airlines or major carriers, our trip alerts notify you when fares drop on your chosen routes. Set your destinations, travel dates, and savings threshold—we'll handle the monitoring.

Get Deal Alerts

When Major Airlines Are Usually Better

There are plenty of situations where paying a bit more for American, Delta, United, or Southwest makes more sense than flying a budget carrier. Here's when major airlines usually offer better value for Dallas travelers.

Long Flights (3+ Hours)

Comfort matters more on longer flights. A 4-hour flight from DFW to Seattle or a 5-hour flight to New York becomes noticeably less pleasant when you're crammed into a budget airline's tighter seats with no in-flight entertainment, limited recline, and minimal legroom.

Major carriers offer more legroom, wider seats, in-seat power outlets, Wi-Fi, and often free streaming entertainment on longer routes. If the price difference is only 10–20% after adding bags, the upgrade in comfort is usually worth it for flights over 3 hours.

Trips Requiring Checked Bags or Carry-Ons

If you need a carry-on roller bag or checked bags, budget airline fees can quickly erase the base fare savings. A family of four flying Spirit with one carry-on and one checked bag each will pay substantial fees that might make American's or Southwest's bundled pricing cheaper overall.

Southwest is especially competitive here since they include two free checked bags per person. If you're traveling with kids, sports equipment, or extended-trip luggage, Southwest's fare might look higher than Spirit's base fare but end up significantly cheaper once you add baggage fees.

American, Delta, and United all include a standard carry-on in regular economy fares (though basic economy may restrict this). If you're bringing a roller bag, compare the total cost including the budget airline's carry-on fee before assuming they're cheaper.

When You Need Better Schedules or Loyalty Benefits

Major carriers fly more daily frequencies on popular routes from Dallas, giving you better departure time options and more backup flights if something goes wrong. American alone operates hundreds of daily departures from DFW, making rebooking significantly easier during delays or cancellations.

If you have elite status or a co-branded credit card, major carriers offer benefits like free checked bags, priority boarding, seat upgrades, and easier changes. These perks can make the effective cost of flying a major carrier much lower than the sticker price suggests.

Business travelers and frequent flyers almost always get better value from major carriers due to loyalty programs, upgradeable fares, and the ability to credit miles toward future trips. Budget airlines don't offer the same loyalty ecosystem.

When the Price Difference Is Minimal (Under 20%)

If Spirit's total cost (base fare + bags + seats) is only 10–15% cheaper than American's regular economy fare,the major carrier almost always offers better value. You get more legroom, better customer service, more rebooking options, and fewer restrictions.

Example: Spirit's total cost comes out to $220 per person, and American's regular economy is $250. That $30 difference buys you a carry-on that fits in the overhead, advance seat selection, easier changes if needed, and more comfortable seating. For most travelers, that's worth the extra cost.

Cost Comparison Scenarios (How to Calculate Your Break-Even Point)

The key to choosing between budget airlines and major carriers is calculating total trip cost, not just comparing base fares. Here's how to break down the numbers for your specific travel situation.

Budget Airline Fare + Common Fees

Start with the base fare. This is what you see advertised—the seat and a personal item (small backpack or purse that fits under the seat).

Add carry-on fees if you need a roller bag that goes in the overhead bin. Fees vary by airline and route, but expect to pay extra for this. Booking the bag during online check-in is usually cheaper than adding it at the airport.

Add checked bag fees if applicable. First checked bag, second checked bag, overweight bags—all cost extra. If you're traveling with family or for an extended trip, these fees add up quickly.

Consider seat selection. Most budget airlines charge for advance seat selection. If you don't pay, they'll assign you a random seat at check-in. Families traveling together often need to pay for seats to sit near each other.

Major Airline Fare + What's Included

Regular economy on American, Delta, or United includes a standard carry-on bag (overhead bin), seat selection (though not always free for basic economy), and the ability to make changes (usually for a fee). This is the baseline to compare against.

Southwest includes more: Two free checked bags, no change fees, free same-day standby, and seat selection (open seating, but you can pick when you board). If you're checking bags or value flexibility, Southwest's effective price is often much lower than the base fare suggests.

Basic economy fares on major carriers have restrictions (no carry-on on some routes, last to board, no changes), but they still typically beat budget airlines on comfort and rebooking options. Compare basic economy to budget airlines, and regular economy to budget airlines + all fees.

How to Evaluate Your Personal Break-Even Point

Step 1: Write down the total cost for each option. Budget airline base fare + all fees you'll need (bags, seats) vs. major airline base fare (which usually includes carry-on and seat selection).

Step 2: Calculate the percentage difference. If the budget airline is 30%+ cheaper after fees, it's probably worth it for short flights with flexible schedules. If it's only 10–15% cheaper, the major carrier usually offers better value.

Step 3: Factor in your priorities. Do you value comfort, schedule reliability, and customer service? Or are you purely optimizing for lowest price? There's no wrong answer—just different priorities.

Real-world example: You're flying DFW to Orlando with one carry-on and no checked bags. Spirit's base fare plus carry-on fee totals $180. American's regular economy is $210. That $30 difference buys you more legroom, easier changes, and better rebooking options if there's a delay. For a 3-hour flight, most travelers find that worth it.

Compare deals across all airlines automatically

Stop manually checking Spirit vs American vs Southwest. Set up trip alerts for your route and we'll show you when any airline drops below your target price. See all options and choose the best value when deals appear.

Set Up Alerts

Final Decision Guide for DFW Travelers

Choosing between budget airlines and major carriers isn't about "good" or "bad" airlines—it's about matching the right airline to your specific trip. Here's a quick checklist to guide your decision.

Quick Decision Checklist

Situations Where Each Option "Wins"

Budget airline wins: DFW to Las Vegas for a long weekend. You're packing light (just a backpack), the flight is 2.5 hours, and you have flexible dates. Spirit's base fare is significantly cheaper than American's, and you don't need any add-ons. Clear budget airline victory.

Major airline wins: DFW to Seattle for a business conference. You need a carry-on with work materials, the flight is 4 hours, and you have a meeting the morning you arrive. American's higher base fare includes the carry-on, offers better rebooking options if there's a delay, and provides more legroom for the long flight. Clear major carrier win.

Depends on your priorities: DFW to Orlando with family. Spirit's base fare is cheaper, but after adding carry-ons and seat selection for four people, it's only 15% less than Southwest. Southwest includes two free checked bags, no change fees, and easier family seating. If you value flexibility and might check bags, Southwest wins. If you're truly packing ultra-light and prioritize lowest price, Spirit could work.

The right answer depends on your trip. There's no universal "best" airline—only the best airline for your specific route, baggage needs, schedule, and priorities. Calculate total cost, consider your comfort threshold, and choose accordingly.

Final Tips for Dallas Travelers

• Always calculate total trip cost, not just base fares. Add bags, seats, and any other fees you'll actually need before comparing airlines.
• Short flights and light packing favor budget airlines. Long flights and checked bags usually favor major carriers or Southwest.
• Schedule reliability matters more for time-critical travel. Major carriers offer more rebooking options when things go wrong.
• Don't assume budget airlines are always cheaper. Once fees are added, major carriers (especially Southwest) can be the better value.
• For destinations within 3–4 hours of Dallas, consider driving if you're traveling with family or need a car at your destination.
• Use elite status and credit card benefits to your advantage. Free checked bags and seat upgrades make major carriers significantly cheaper for frequent flyers.

Budget airlines like Spirit and Frontier can offer genuine savings for Dallas travelers, but they're not the right choice for every trip. Match the airline to your specific needs—route distance, baggage requirements, schedule flexibility, and comfort priorities—and you'll get the best value every time.

Track deals on all your routes

Whether you prefer budget airlines or major carriers, we'll notify you when fares drop on your chosen routes. Set up personalized trip alerts and compare deals across all airlines automatically.

Start for FreeGo Premium